A Dueling Pens Posting by Thelma and Louise
I don't know how much money that dude who wrote "The Five People you Meet in Heaven" made for that book, but I can say without hesitation that I resent every dime of it. Does he think there will only be five people? He's number six? Is this the theory? And why isn't Elvis one of them? (Obviously, I have not read the book. Please don't email me about how this book has changed your life).
BUT, I'm sitting in the lobby of this snazzy hotel in Jackson Hole, Wyoming a few months ago and they have this roaring fire in the lobby. Actually two roaring fires, on opposite sides of the room, but that's not the point. The point is that there are these young, strapping men whose job it is to keep these fires burning (reason enough to check out this hotel...). The strapping young man in charge of the fire where I'm sitting notices the flames are waning, so he makes the trek outside to get more

wood while I order another toddy for the body. It's cold. I'm tired. Fire good. Strapping young man good. Toddy for the body good.
So he comes back in and throws this thing on the fire:
My writer's imagination begins to run wild. It looks just like a bench at a bus stop in hell! (Perhaps one too many toddies....) I start to think about the five people you meet in hell. Now THIS is a useful concept. First, if you end up blowing your turn with the buzzer and your spin of the eternal destiny wheel lands on "bankrupt" and you find yourself in need of an extinguisher and a supply of bottled water (you're already in hell, so what do you care if people know you ruin the environment by drinking bottled water?), you'll be prepared. You'll know what to expect. You can have your questions, confrontations and, in appropriate cases, heavy blunt objects at the ready. And secondly - and this is waaaaaaay more important - perhaps you can avoid these people in real life so you don't have to share a bench with them ever. Anywhere. And they can go straight to hell without you. So to speak.
Benchwarmer #1: The Underminer (you know who you are)
Now, I have never personally seen a reality show. I stopped watching televison years ago (don't ask). But key to undersanding the Underminer is to understand that, for her, life is one long episode of Survivor. The tricky part is that no one else knows they're on the show! This is the genius of the underminer. With this exclusive vantage point, imagine the chaos, the destruction, the utter wasteland of devastation the Underminer can leave in her wake! Imagine how easy it is to run a bowling ball right through a group of co-workers, friends, or an entire family. This person is the Casius who whispers in your ear about an employee (see also: Gossip, below). It will sound something like this: "I hate to mention this, but I saw Sara rifling your desk the other day. I know you trust her and everything, and she really does seem so genuine. I'd hate to think that she'd do anything like that. But I thought you should know."
Your response, of course, is gratitude. Toward the Underminer. This is because her identity has not yet been revealed. You trust her. In fact, you value her loyalty. You decide to keep an eye on Sara.
Over the course of the next months, however, the Underminer will slowly erode your confidence in Sara. Until eventually, all you see when you look at Sara is an unlikeable, dishonest loser. So eventually you fire her. Boom. Sara's off the island.
The art here is in the backstory. See, the Underminer has been doing the same thing to YOU the entire time! Whispering into Sara's ear about you and about how you're starting to turn against her and that you're really capricious and moody and not to be trusted. Ever.
And then... guess what? You show up at a party a month later and who are BFF's? Yep, the Underminer and Sara. If you are naaive (as I once was, and as I'm still prone to be) your loyalty to people can blind you to this scam. Before you know it, they're all gone. Except you. Standing on your desert island wishing you had Wilson to talk to - that volleyball that Tom Hanks talks to in the movie. Everyone else is on the new island, which is populated entirely by people loyal to the Underminer and suspicious of you. She is now the star of the show.
Coming Soon: Part 2: The Poacher